Demonstration Project Objectives:
- Conduct outreach to air-to-water manufacturers with a presence in Wisconsin and the capability to provide design support.
- Demonstrate AWHP in a mix of retrofit and new construction sites across three single-family buildings and one multifamily building in Wisconsin. Recruit at least one site with AWHP domestic hot water and AWHP hydronic cooling.
- Identify key characteristics (i.e. climate zones, age, fuel type, level of weatherization, hydronic distribution emitter type and size) that make a home a promising candidate for an air-to-water heat pump.
- Document installation barriers, system failures, changes to operating parameters, and adjustments required during system monitoring.
- Quantify the costs associated with AWHP systems and retrofits, including equipment, installation, operation, and maintenance costs.
- Quantify AWHP system performance, including electricity consumption, backup fuel use, heating and cooling efficiencies, operating costs, and maintenance requirements, and compare performance against conventional heating systems where applicable.
- Examine the performance of integrated domestic hot water and space heating systems to determine whether they provide adequate heating and hot water under real-world operating conditions.
- Understand the perspective of AWHP users and installers through surveys and interviews.
- Produce a draft Technical Reference Manual (TRM) workpaper to support the inclusion of AWHPs as a prescriptive measure within the portfolio.
Key Outcomes
- Energy savings and operating costs varied by site. Three of the four buildings achieved energy savings of 40%, 48%, and 53%, while one experienced only about 6% savings due to design and control problems. Replacing electric resistance heating reduced annual operating costs by up to approximately $1,300, whereas replacing natural gas heating increased costs by up to approximately $800 under the utility rates observed in the study.
- System efficiency varied by application. Space heating coefficients of performance (COPs) at the better performing sites were approximately 2.7-3.2; domestic hot water COPs averaged approximately 1.2-1.5.
- Heating fuel influenced operating costs. AWHPs replacing electric resistance heating reduced estimated annual operating costs at the two applicable sites. Gas-baseline sites saw estimated annual operating cost increases.
- Effective design and control practices were identified. These included early technical support, appropriate hydronic system design, integrated backup heating controls, and outdoor-reset controls for supply-water temperature.
Lessons Learned
- New construction and certain retrofits offer the strongest near-term opportunities. New construction systems were simpler to install, while retrofits required careful evaluation of heating loads, existing piping, pumps, and heat emitters. Successful retrofits made targeted system modifications and achieved energy savings above 40%.
- Contractor experience and design support are critical. Installations completed by experienced contractors or supported by manufacturers during early in design and commissioning achieved better results. Limited AWHP-specific experience contributed to system-design errors, control issues, and extensive troubleshooting.
- Controls strongly influence efficiency. Outdoor-reset controls that lower supply-water temperatures in milder weather improved heat pump efficiency. Poor integration of heat pump and backup boiler controls increased reliance on backup heating and reduced savings.
- Domestic hot water (DHW) requires special consideration. Systems serving both space heating and hot water had lower efficiency for DHW, with COPs of approximately 1.2–1.5 compared with roughly 3.0 for space heating. Tank sizing, temperature setpoints, backup heating, and residents’ hot water consumption all affected performance.
Learn More
Field Study Report: Air-to-Water Heat Pump Final Report
Questions?
Contact the Future Focus team with questions at futurefocus@focusonenergy.com.